• <div class="header-image" style="background-image: url(/live/image/gid/4/2801_V6N8_Header.rev.1537380633.jpg);">​</div><div class="header-background-color"/>

Clearing, Levees, and Systemic Risk

May 13, 2015

Consider the levee – that barrier we often build next to flood-prone rivers. During a heavy rain, the levee prevents water from flooding into a nearby town, from testing and probably damaging the structural integrity of its buildings. After all, the levee has been built with only one purpose in mind, dealing with water, and therefore it does so much more effectively than most buildings.

By Modibo Camara, SAS’16

But let’s assume there is a crisis. A big storm hits, causing major flooding, enough to breach the levees (like e.g. in New Orleans after Katrina). Because a barrier was present, water was allowed to build up until it finally released in an explosive rush towards the town, magnifying the storm’s impact beyond what the town might have experienced without the levee. The levee is effective until it isn’t, and when it isn’t, it ceases to be the solution to the problem, instead becoming the propagator.

This summer, I interned at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), an independent government agency tasked with regulating the financial derivatives markets. At this point, you might be wondering what levees have to do with derivatives, and you’d be right to ask, because they don’t have much in common. But the levee analogy is how I’ve come to view an important new provision in the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010: the central clearing requirement. The new mandate applies a century-old practice, already common in futures and options exchanges, to various classes of over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives.[1]

What is clearing? It’s is a process by which two parties to a financial trade (i.e. counterparties) use an intermediary (i.e. clearing house) to guarantee the contract’s fulfillment. Here’s a very stylized diagram to explain it:


The Cearing ProcesThe Clearing Process 

Like levees, clearing houses are equipped to deal with counterparty risk (or flooding) and allow authorities to deal with crises at a few isolated points. By pooling risk (like an insurance company) and establishing necessary safeguards against worst-case scenarios, they are more robust than individual traders, and thereby reduce counterparty risk across the system. Further, by routing all trades through clearing houses, the market is simplified from a tangled web of bilateral transactions to a multi-radial structure, wherein all trades connect directly to a few central institutions.

In response to the 2008 financial crisis, Dodd-Frank and subsequent CFTC rules now require a much larger portion of the derivatives trades to be cleared by legally designated clearing houses. Where, then, do the problems arise? In a word (or two): systemic risk. Centralized clearing does not end systemic risk, nor even counterparty risk. Instead, like the levee, it rearranges that risk. It concentrates all the pressure of a crisis onto a few key points, relying on them to protect ordinary traders – with potentially devastating results should the clearing house fail. Of course, the typical clearing house has (and is required to have) substantial risk management provisions, including default guarantee funds, high membership standards (all cleared trades have to go through approved institutions), collateral/margin requirements (more on that in a bit), and reliable short-term creditors. That does not make them immune, however, and a clearing house can be put under extraordinary stress during a market calamity. After a major price movement, counterparty failures are likely to be correlated and occur on one position of a trade, which would leave the clearing house with a large open position at seriously disadvantageous prices. Moreover, even if the clearing house can withstand an initial movement, it might be vulnerable to subsequent shocks after having depleted its emergency funds.

Given the economies of scale inherent in clearing, each individual clearing house is likely to be large and systemically important – several of them have already been designated as such by the Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC). The failure of a clearing house would affect all parties – not just those who traded with defaulting members, guaranteeing the spread of contagion across the industry. The shock of its failure could panic traders, and a cessation of its operations could (literally) freeze the marketplace and all assets therein. This is precisely the sort of issue that regulators have been trying to prevent in the wake of 2008. Moreover, it is not just hypothetical. Clearing house failures have occurred several times in recent history, the most famous example being the Hong Kong Futures Exchange collapse in 1987.[2]

However, even a solvent clearing house could cause trouble during a crisis. Clearing houses generally collect liquid collateral (e.g. cash) from counterparties, to be offset losses in case of their default. Many reserve the right to demand extra collateral when the market is especially volatile. Indeed, it appears sensible for a clearing house to demand an extra buffer against losses when market-related risks are higher. However, the effect of all clearing houses demanding extra payments can put great stress on already-pressured financial markets, extracting liquidity precisely at the time when it is most needed.[3]

There are a few other issues related to clearing, but they seem to be less problematic. One is moral hazard – just like the presence of levees could encourage lax building standards, traders might be less careful in choosing counterparties if they expect the clearing house to protect them from default. Another is competition between clearing houses, and a possible vicious cycle of deteriorating risk management practices in order to capture more market share. However, the CFTC has taken steps (particularly, in Part 39 of Title 17 of the CFR) to mitigate this possibility and to monitor excess risk-taking.

Overall, I don’t believe that Dodd-Frank’s clearing requirement was bad policy – nor do I have anything against levees. Aside from clearing houses being better equipped for a crisis, there are real advantages associated with this new distribution of risk. It’s far easier to assess market distress and provide liquidity support to a few ailing clearing houses than to a highly interconnected network of traders.[4] Furthermore, some have compared the clearing house can act as a sort of disinterested market watcher – it has a stake in the stability of the system, but, ideally, cannot profit off distorting prices or manipulating markets.[5] And as mentioned, FSOC has already designated several clearing houses as ‘systemically important’, and the CFTC and other regulators have taken important steps to ensure active oversight and appropriate standards among clearing houses.

If well maintained and regulated, with appropriate emergency support when necessary, clearing houses will simply be a routine part of our financial plumbing. The biggest threat today, as in the mid 2000s, is complacency: clearing does not ‘fix’ systemic risk, and it must be watched, but under due vigilance it can do a lot to improve our financial system.

 

Disclaimer: these thoughts are entirely those of the author, were written privately, and do not represent or reflect the views of the CFTC or its staff.


[1] To get an idea of the size of these markets and their clearing rates today, see the CFTC’s weekly swaps report (http://www.cftc.gov/MarketReports/SwapsReports/L1GrossExpCS). For those new to the topic, however, please note that notional value almost always overstates the value that actually changes hands.

 

[2] See the 2011 speech delivered by Paul Tucker at the Bank of England, on page 4 (http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/speeches/2011/speech501.pdf). Also see Ben Bernanke’s 1990 paper, Clearing and Settlement During the Crash (http://www.jscc.co.jp/en/data/5), which discusses stresses faced by US clearing houses during the same crisis and emergency actions taken by the Fed.

 

[3] See Craig Pirrong’s 2011 paper, The Economics of Central Clearing: Theory and Practice. It was written under the ISDA, and covers many of the topics that I mention here, only at far greater depth.

 

4 This also raises the question of why central clearing can’t be a public service, where the clearing house is an explicitly guaranteed federal institution. At the least, this would avoid any principle agent problems related to clearing houses’ dual role as for-profit corporations and system stabilizers. Interestingly, a 2014 speech delivered by Paul Tucker, entitled Are Clearing Houses the New Central Banks? considers the idea (http://www.chicagofed.org/digital_assets/others/events/2014/annual_over_the_counter_derivatives_symposium/tucker_clearinghouses_new_central_banks_tucker_2014.pdf).

 

[5] It has been pointed out to me, however, that since clearing houses thrive on volume, they may have an incentive to distort the market in that direction. As with any institution, particularly for-profit ones, their interests will never fully align with those of society.

Student Blog Disclaimer
  • The views expressed on the Student Blog are the author’s opinions and don’t necessarily represent the Penn Wharton Public Policy Initiative’s strategies, recommendations, or opinions.

PENN WHARTON PPI
RESOURCE SPOTLIGHT:

  • <h3>National Bureau of Economic Research (Public Use Data Archive)</h3><p><img width="180" height="43" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/180/height/43/478_nber.rev.1407530465.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image478 lw_align_right" data-max-w="329" data-max-h="79"/>Founded in 1920, the <strong>National Bureau of Economic Research</strong> is a private, nonprofit, nonpartisan research organization dedicated to promoting a greater understanding of how the economy works. The NBER is committed to undertaking and disseminating unbiased economic research among public policymakers, business professionals, and the academic community.</p><p> Quick Link to <strong>Public Use Data Archive</strong>: <a href="http://www.nber.org/data/" target="_blank">http://www.nber.org/data/</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>USDA Nutrition Assistance Data</h3><p><img width="180" height="124" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/180/height/124/485_usda_logo.rev.1407789238.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image485 lw_align_right" srcset="/live/image/scale/2x/gid/4/width/180/height/124/485_usda_logo.rev.1407789238.jpg 2x, /live/image/scale/3x/gid/4/width/180/height/124/485_usda_logo.rev.1407789238.jpg 3x" data-max-w="1233" data-max-h="850"/>Data and research regarding the following <strong>USDA Nutrition Assistance</strong> programs are available through this site:</p><ul><li>Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) </li><li>Food Distribution Programs </li><li>School Meals </li><li>Women, Infants and Children </li></ul><p> Quick link: <a href="http://www.fns.usda.gov/data-and-statistics" target="_blank">http://www.fns.usda.gov/data-and-statistics</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>NOAA National Climatic Data Center</h3><p><img width="200" height="198" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/200/height/198/483_noaa_logo.rev.1407788692.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image483 lw_align_left" srcset="/live/image/scale/2x/gid/4/width/200/height/198/483_noaa_logo.rev.1407788692.jpg 2x, /live/image/scale/3x/gid/4/width/200/height/198/483_noaa_logo.rev.1407788692.jpg 3x" data-max-w="954" data-max-h="945"/>NOAA’s National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) is responsible for preserving, monitoring, assessing, and providing public access to the Nation’s treasure of <strong>climate and historical weather data and information</strong>.</p><p> Quick link to home page: <a href="http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/" target="_blank">http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/</a></p><p> Quick link to NCDC’s climate and weather datasets, products, and various web pages and resources: <a href="http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/quick-links" target="_blank">http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/quick-links</a></p><p> Quick link to Text & Map Search: <a href="http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdo-web/" target="_blank">http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdo-web/</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>The Penn World Table</h3><p> The Penn World Table provides purchasing power parity and national income accounts converted to international prices for 189 countries/territories for some or all of the years 1950-2010.</p><p><a href="https://pwt.sas.upenn.edu/php_site/pwt71/pwt71_form.php" target="_blank">Quick link.</a> </p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>National Center for Education Statistics</h3><p><strong><img width="400" height="80" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/400/height/80/479_nces.rev.1407787656.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image479 lw_align_right" data-max-w="400" data-max-h="80"/>The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) is the primary federal entity for collecting and analyzing data related to education in the U.S. and other nations.</strong> NCES is located within the U.S. Department of Education and the Institute of Education Sciences. NCES has an extensive Statistical Standards Program that consults and advises on methodological and statistical aspects involved in the design, collection, and analysis of data collections in the Center. To learn more about the NCES, <a href="http://nces.ed.gov/about/" target="_blank">click here</a>.</p><p> Quick link to NCES Data Tools: <a href="http://nces.ed.gov/datatools/index.asp?DataToolSectionID=4" target="_blank">http://nces.ed.gov/datatools/index.asp?DataToolSectionID=4</a></p><p> Quick link to Quick Tables and Figures: <a href="http://nces.ed.gov/quicktables/" target="_blank">http://nces.ed.gov/quicktables/</a></p><p> Quick link to NCES Fast Facts (Note: The primary purpose of the Fast Facts website is to provide users with concise information on a range of educational issues, from early childhood to adult learning.): <a href="http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/" target="_blank">http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/#</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>The World Bank Data (U.S.)</h3><p><img width="130" height="118" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/130/height/118/484_world-bank-logo.rev.1407788945.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image484 lw_align_left" srcset="/live/image/scale/2x/gid/4/width/130/height/118/484_world-bank-logo.rev.1407788945.jpg 2x, /live/image/scale/3x/gid/4/width/130/height/118/484_world-bank-logo.rev.1407788945.jpg 3x" data-max-w="1406" data-max-h="1275"/>The <strong>World Bank</strong> provides World Development Indicators, Surveys, and data on Finances and Climate Change.</p><p> Quick link: <a href="http://data.worldbank.org/country/united-states" target="_blank">http://data.worldbank.org/country/united-states</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>Federal Aviation Administration: Accident & Incident Data</h3><p><img width="100" height="100" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/100/height/100/80_faa-logo.rev.1402681347.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image80 lw_align_left" srcset="/live/image/scale/2x/gid/4/width/100/height/100/80_faa-logo.rev.1402681347.jpg 2x, /live/image/scale/3x/gid/4/width/100/height/100/80_faa-logo.rev.1402681347.jpg 3x" data-max-w="550" data-max-h="550"/>The NTSB issues an accident report following each investigation. These reports are available online for reports issued since 1996, with older reports coming online soon. The reports listing is sortable by the event date, report date, city, and state.</p><p> Quick link: <a href="http://www.faa.gov/data_research/accident_incident/" target="_blank">http://www.faa.gov/data_research/accident_incident/</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>Internal Revenue Service: Tax Statistics</h3><p><img width="155" height="200" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/155/height/200/486_irs_logo.rev.1407789424.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image486 lw_align_left" srcset="/live/image/scale/2x/gid/4/width/155/height/200/486_irs_logo.rev.1407789424.jpg 2x" data-max-w="463" data-max-h="596"/>Find statistics on business tax, individual tax, charitable and exempt organizations, IRS operations and budget, and income (SOI), as well as statistics by form, products, publications, papers, and other IRS data.</p><p> Quick link to <strong>Tax Statistics, where you will find a wide range of tables, articles, and data</strong> that describe and measure elements of the U.S. tax system: <a href="http://www.irs.gov/uac/Tax-Stats-2" target="_blank">http://www.irs.gov/uac/Tax-Stats-2</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>HUD State of the Cities Data Systems</h3><p><strong><img width="200" height="200" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/200/height/200/482_hud_logo.rev.1407788472.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image482 lw_align_left" srcset="/live/image/scale/2x/gid/4/width/200/height/200/482_hud_logo.rev.1407788472.jpg 2x, /live/image/scale/3x/gid/4/width/200/height/200/482_hud_logo.rev.1407788472.jpg 3x" data-max-w="612" data-max-h="613"/>The SOCDS provides data for individual Metropolitan Areas, Central Cities, and Suburbs.</strong> It is a portal for non-national data made available through a number of outside institutions (e.g. Census, BLS, FBI and others).</p><p> Quick link: <a href="http://www.huduser.org/portal/datasets/socds.html" target="_blank">http://www.huduser.org/portal/datasets/socds.html</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>MapStats</h3><p> A feature of FedStats, MapStats allows users to search for <strong>state, county, city, congressional district, or Federal judicial district data</strong> (demographic, economic, and geographic).</p><p> Quick link: <a href="http://www.fedstats.gov/mapstats/" target="_blank">http://www.fedstats.gov/mapstats/</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>Congressional Budget Office</h3><p><img width="180" height="180" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/180/height/180/380_cbo-logo.rev.1406822035.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image380 lw_align_right" data-max-w="180" data-max-h="180"/>Since its founding in 1974, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has produced independent analyses of budgetary and economic issues to support the Congressional budget process.</p><p> The agency is strictly nonpartisan and conducts objective, impartial analysis, which is evident in each of the dozens of reports and hundreds of cost estimates that its economists and policy analysts produce each year. CBO does not make policy recommendations, and each report and cost estimate discloses the agency’s assumptions and methodologies. <strong>CBO provides budgetary and economic information in a variety of ways and at various points in the legislative process.</strong> Products include baseline budget projections and economic forecasts, analysis of the President’s budget, cost estimates, analysis of federal mandates, working papers, and more.</p><p> Quick link to Products page: <a href="http://www.cbo.gov/about/our-products" target="_blank">http://www.cbo.gov/about/our-products</a></p><p> Quick link to Topics: <a href="http://www.cbo.gov/topics" target="_blank">http://www.cbo.gov/topics</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>
  • <h3>Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED®)</h3><p><strong><img width="180" height="79" alt="" src="/live/image/gid/4/width/180/height/79/481_fred-logo.rev.1407788243.jpg" class="lw_image lw_image481 lw_align_right" data-max-w="222" data-max-h="97"/>An online database consisting of more than 72,000 economic data time series from 54 national, international, public, and private sources.</strong> FRED®, created and maintained by Research Department at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, goes far beyond simply providing data: It combines data with a powerful mix of tools that help the user understand, interact with, display, and disseminate the data.</p><p> Quick link to data page: <a href="http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/tags/series" target="_blank">http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/tags/series</a></p><p>See all <a href="/data-resources/">data and resources</a> »</p>